MADE FOR EVERYDAY MATH · FREE TO USE
← Back to calculators
Everyday Calc Lab / Free Tool

Rent vs. Buy Calculator – 3, 5 & 7-Year Costs, Break-Even and Home Equity

Rent vs. Buy Calculator – 3, 5 & 7-Year Costs, Break-Even and Home Equity


Should you rent or buy a home — and how long would you need to stay for buying to pay off? Comparing your rent with a mortgage payment is only the beginning. A homebuyer also pays closing costs, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and eventual selling expenses. A renter, meanwhile, might invest the down payment and any monthly cash they save by not owning.

This free rent vs. buy calculator compares both choices over your planned stay. Test 3, 5, 7, or 10 years, then change home appreciation, rent increases, and investment returns to see why the answer can change. The guide below explains every major assumption in plain American English.

Free U.S. housing decision tool

Rent vs. Buy Calculator: Compare the True Costs

Compare the projected financial position of a renter and a homeowner after a planned number of years. Every prefilled number is an illustrative assumption, not a current market average.

Advanced assumptions: taxes, PMI, closing costs, investing

Owner's ongoing expenses

One-time costs and renting details

Calculation method: Both choices start with equal available cash. Money saved upfront and any monthly cost difference is invested by the less expensive option at the selected assumed return. Buying ends with home value minus selling expenses and unpaid mortgage, plus accumulated investment savings; renting ends with invested savings and a returned security deposit. A fixed-rate conventional mortgage is amortized monthly. PMI is simplified and turned off after the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price. This model excludes income-tax deductions, capital-gains taxes, investment taxes, mortgage refinancing, special assessments, major one-time repairs, and the cost of moving. Home price appreciation, interest rate, costs, and returns are assumptions, not forecasts. Nothing is sent to a server.

Is It Cheaper to Rent or Buy a Home?

There is no universal answer, because the result depends on the home, the rental you could live in instead, and how long you expect to stay. Comparing a $2,500 monthly rent with a $2,275 principal-and-interest mortgage payment can make buying look cheaper. But that comparison leaves out property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, repairs, HOA dues, buying closing costs, and costs when you sell. Conversely, a simple sum of rent checks ignores the investments a renter could build with cash that would otherwise go toward a down payment.

That is why a useful rent-versus-buy comparison asks two questions separately: How much cash will I need each month? and What financial position could I have when I move? The second question includes remaining mortgage debt, home sale proceeds, the security deposit you get back as a renter, and the opportunity cost of tying cash up in a home.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's rent-or-buy guidance recommends examining the length of time you expect to stay and testing different assumptions about future home prices. The calculator above turns that advice into a set of numbers you can adjust.

Rent vs. Buy After 3, 5, or 7 Years: Why Your Timeline Matters

Buying a home involves costs both when you purchase it and when you sell it. If you move soon, those costs may consume much of the equity you accumulated through your mortgage payments. The longer you stay, the more time you have to pay down principal and potentially benefit from home price growth — although that growth is not automatic.

Consider a hypothetical $400,000 home with $40,000 down, a 30-year fixed loan at 6.5%, and a comparable rental at $2,500 per month. For illustration, assume 3% annual home appreciation, 3% annual rent increases, 5% annual returns on invested differences, 3% buyer closing costs, 6% selling costs, and the property expenses prefilled above. These are planning inputs, not national averages or predictions.

Housing choice What matters in this example
Renting $2,500 starting rent, renter's insurance, initial security deposit, rent increases, invested savings
Buying $360,000 mortgage, taxes, insurance, estimated PMI, HOA, maintenance, closing costs, sale proceeds
Comparison horizon 3 years vs. 5 years vs. 7 years, then other possible move dates

Under the example assumptions, renting comes out ahead by roughly $25,000 after three years and $14,000 after five years. Around year seven, the two strategies are close to break-even. These figures come from the specific cash-flow and home-sale model described below; changing the purchase price, future home value, or investment return can shift the crossing point considerably. Use the calculator to test your own figures rather than applying a universal “buy after seven years” rule.

What Counts as the True Monthly Cost of Owning a Home?

A mortgage's principal and interest are not the complete monthly cost of owning a property. The typical budget also needs to consider property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance, and any applicable mortgage insurance or HOA charges. The CFPB describes these additional costs as essential parts of understanding housing affordability.

Expense How to think about it
Principal and interest Scheduled mortgage repayment; part reduces the debt and builds equity
Property tax Local tax; actual assessed value and exemptions may differ from purchase price
Homeowners insurance Insurance coverage paid to the insurer or through escrow
PMI Possible conventional-loan insurance when the down payment is below 20%
HOA / condo dues Association charges, often separate from the mortgage bill
Maintenance Money set aside for repairs, replacements, and ongoing upkeep

Be especially careful not to treat the entire mortgage payment as an unrecoverable expense. The interest is a financing cost, but the principal payment reduces debt. Our model calculates the loan balance over time and incorporates that balance into eventual sale proceeds. This prevents counting principal paid as a permanent loss and overlooking the equity it created.

For a more detailed breakdown of the mortgage payment itself, find our Mortgage Calculator With Taxes, Insurance, PMI & HOA. That companion tool focuses on the monthly housing budget and additional principal payments; this page focuses on choosing between two housing paths.

Down Payment vs. Security Deposit: Compare Your Starting Cash

A buyer typically needs a down payment plus closing costs. A renter might need a security deposit, application or broker fees, and the first month's rent. A security deposit is not necessarily a permanent cost: under the simplifying assumption in this tool, it is returned in full when the tenancy ends. It still matters because money held as a deposit cannot be invested during that time.

The CFPB says a rough early planning range for mortgage closing costs is 2% to 5% of the home price, not including the down payment. On a $400,000 home, 3% closing costs would be $12,000. Together with a $40,000 down payment, that is $52,000 in initial buyer cash under our example assumptions. Source: CFPB closing-cost and homebuying budget guide.

Meanwhile, a renter paying $2,500 per month with a refundable one-month deposit and no broker fee ties up only $2,500 at the start. The remaining difference could be invested. This is the first source of the renter's modeled investment balance, which is why a fair comparison needs more than a mortgage-payment calculator.

What Is Opportunity Cost in a Rent vs. Buy Calculator?

Opportunity cost means the potential return on money you use for one choice instead of another. If you spend $52,000 upfront on buying, that cash is no longer available for a separate investment. But if you rent and spend more per month than the comparable homeowner, the homeowner might invest the monthly difference. Both effects belong in the comparison.

Our calculator starts the two strategies with an equal available cash budget. Any difference between the initial buyer cash and renter upfront cash goes into the investment portfolio of the choice that required less upfront. In each subsequent month, the option with the lower housing cash outlay invests the difference at your selected annual return. The portfolios compound monthly, using an equivalent monthly rate based on the annual assumption.

This design has an important advantage: it does not automatically favor renting by awarding the renter investment earnings while ignoring the homeowner's potential savings. It also separates cash-flow affordability from ending housing-related wealth. Returns may be positive or negative; they are scenario assumptions rather than promises of investment performance.

How Does Home Appreciation Change the Rent-or-Buy Break-Even Point?

When you buy, the future home value affects how much money you may recover if you sell. When you rent, the future growth of your invested savings affects the alternative financial position. Both figures are uncertain and can move in opposite directions.

For example, with an assumed 3% annual home appreciation rate, a $400,000 property is modeled at roughly $491,950 after seven years. Before you can treat that as money in your pocket, you still must subtract selling costs and the remaining mortgage balance. If the home's price fails to rise, or falls, the projected net sale proceeds can be much lower.

Try three runs with your actual expected move date unchanged: 0% home appreciation, 2% appreciation, and 4% appreciation. Then hold those assumptions steady and vary the investment return. Watching the result change is much more informative than selecting whichever scenario produces your preferred answer.

Why Closing Costs and Selling Costs Can Favor Renting for a Short Stay

Homeowners often encounter two transaction-cost events: purchasing and selling. In our model, buyer closing costs are paid at the start, while selling costs are charged as a percentage of the property's projected future sale price. The proceeds are reduced by the mortgage balance that remains at the time of the sale.

The CFPB warns that moving again within a few years can be financially expensive for homeowners because the costs of selling and purchasing can outweigh the advantages of ownership. It is worth comparing likely housing tenure before using a lower mortgage rate or a projected house-price gain as the deciding factor.

Closing and selling charges are not the same in every transaction. Enter amounts that reflect local transfer taxes, lender charges, title costs, and the selling arrangement you expect. For example, a 6% selling-cost assumption should not be presented as a legally fixed real estate commission; actual commissions and fees depend on the transaction and are negotiable where applicable.

How Do Rent Increases and Maintenance Costs Affect the Answer?

Future rent affects the renter's cash outflow, while future repairs and operating expenses affect the owner's. A lease may hold rent steady for a period, then increase at renewal. A homeowner's mortgage principal-and-interest payment can remain fixed under a fixed-rate loan, but property taxes, insurance premiums, maintenance bills, and HOA dues can change.

This calculator increases rent at the chosen annual rate starting in year two. It separately increases estimated property-tax expense, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, and renter's insurance each year at the chosen ownership-expense inflation rate. Maintenance uses a percentage of the projected home value, which rises or falls with the home-appreciation assumption. These simplified growth rules are spelled out so readers know exactly what is being compared.

One surprise: a home can gain value while becoming more expensive to own each month. Equity and cash flow are different things. A buyer needs both a viable monthly budget and an understanding of the equity they may recover when leaving.

Does PMI Last for the Entire Mortgage?

For many conventional mortgages, a down payment below 20% can mean private mortgage insurance. The CFPB explains that, on eligible loans, borrowers may request cancellation at an 80% original-value threshold when the requirements are satisfied, while scheduled automatic termination generally applies at 78% of the home's original value if the borrower is current. FHA and VA loan structures differ. CFPB: When can PMI be removed?

For a transparent conventional-loan estimate, our model shows starting PMI below 20% down, then turns it off once the scheduled outstanding mortgage balance reaches 78% of the original purchase price. Real PMI cancellation depends on the loan and servicing conditions; if you have an actual lender quote, use that figure to refine your decision. The model does not apply FHA mortgage insurance premiums or VA funding fees.

Rent vs. Buy Is About More Than a Number

The dollar comparison is useful, but it does not measure every reason someone might choose a home. Renting may offer flexibility to change cities, avoid large repair bills, or test a neighborhood. Buying may offer more control over the property, predictability in mortgage principal and interest, and the chance to build equity. Fannie Mae's renting-versus-buying guide discusses these practical trade-offs.

Consider the real housing alternatives available to you. Comparing an apartment near your job with a much larger house far from work can overlook commuting time, utility costs, and quality-of-life differences. Comparing two reasonably similar homes gives a more useful financial starting point.

How to Use This Rent vs. Buy Calculator Before Making a Decision

Start with a local home listing and a realistic alternative rental. Enter a mortgage interest rate from a lender quote, your actual down payment, property-tax and insurance estimates, and the number of years you expect to stay. Then examine the monthly cash-flow difference and the projected wealth difference when you move as separate results.

Next, change your planned move date from three to five to seven years. Run a modest home-price-growth case and a weaker one. If your timeline or job situation is uncertain, test a shorter stay as well. A choice that looks attractive after 15 years might look very different after three years.

For planning the down payment, see our Savings Goal Calculator. For detailed monthly mortgage expenses, see the Mortgage Payment Calculator.

Rent vs. Buy Calculator FAQ

Is buying always cheaper than renting after five years?

No fixed year applies to every market. The result varies with purchase and rental prices, financing, transaction costs, expected appreciation, local taxes, investment returns, and how long you stay. Enter actual local numbers and compare several move dates.

Should I compare rent with only my mortgage principal and interest?

No. Add property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance, any PMI, and HOA fees to estimate an owner's monthly housing cash outlay. Also account for closing costs and potential selling expenses.

Why does the calculator count investment returns for renters?

A renter may be able to invest cash that would otherwise be tied up in a down payment and closing costs. The model also allows homeowners to invest monthly savings if owning costs less than renting. It compares both choices under the same investment-rate assumption.

Does mortgage principal count as a housing cost or equity?

It is a cash payment each month, but it also reduces the debt on the property. The calculator deducts the remaining mortgage balance from sale proceeds, so principal repayments are reflected in growing equity rather than treated as permanently lost cash.

How does a security deposit affect the comparison?

The calculator treats the deposit as cash that is unavailable for investing while you rent, then assumes it is refunded in full when you leave. If your actual deposit may be partially withheld, adjust expectations accordingly.

Are tax deductions included in the calculation?

No. The model excludes mortgage-interest deductions, property-tax deduction effects, home-sale capital-gains taxes, and investment-income taxes because actual eligibility and tax treatment vary by household and year. This keeps its before-tax comparison transparent.

What happens if home prices fall?

Enter a negative annual home-appreciation rate. The calculator projects a lower sale price, subtracts selling costs and the mortgage balance, and compares the result with the renter's investment position.

What if I stay longer than my mortgage term?

Once the modeled mortgage is paid off, scheduled principal and interest fall to zero. Property tax, insurance, HOA, and maintenance continue, and the comparison continues investing whichever option has the lower monthly housing cash outlay.

Can the rent-vs-buy break-even year change?

Yes. It can shift when you change rent increases, home appreciation, interest rate, investment returns, maintenance, or selling costs. The displayed crossing year is the first modeled year buying pulls ahead in ending housing-related wealth within a 30-year window, not an unchanging deadline.

Use the numbers to ask a better question: not simply “Is the mortgage cheaper than my rent?” but “Which housing choice fits my monthly budget and leaves me in a stronger financial position at the time I may actually move?”

Just a little heads-up

Our calculators are here to make everyday math easier. For important decisions, check the relevant official details, too.